Is South Dakota a One-Party Consent State?
Yes, South Dakota is a one-party consent state: in general, you can record a call you take part in.[1][2][3]
South Dakota is a one-party consent state: you can record a phone call, video call or conversation you take part in, or one where a participant agrees. Recording without any party's consent is a Class 5 felony (SDCL § 23A-35A-20).[1][2][3]
- Phone calls
- One-party consent
- Video calls
- One-party consent
- In person
- One-party consent
- Penalty
- Recording a call or conversation without the consent of any party, or helping someone do it, is a Class 5 felony (§ 23A-35A-20): up to 5 years in prison, and a fine of up to $10,000 may be added (§ 22-6-1). Installing a recording device in a private place without consent (§ 22-21-1) is a Class 1 misdemeanor: up to 1 year in county jail, a $2,000 fine, or both (§ 22-6-2).[1][4][5][6]
- Iowa: one-party consent
- Minnesota: one-party consent
- Montana: all-party consent
- Nebraska: one-party consent
- North Dakota: one-party consent
- South Dakota: one-party consent (this page)
- Wyoming: one-party consent
- One-party consent
- All-party consent
All-party (often called two-party) consent means everyone on the call agrees to the recording; one-party consent means one person on the call, who can be the one recording, is enough.
Last reviewed on . Every fact links to its source. Not legal advice.
What does South Dakota recording law say?
“Except as provided in § 23A-35A-21, a person is guilty of a Class 5 felony who is not: (1) A sender or receiver of a communication who ... overhears or records a communication ... without the consent of either a sender or receiver of the communication;”
“A person present during a conversation or discussion who intentionally and by means of an eavesdropping device overhears or records the conversation or discussion ... without the consent of a party to the conversation or discussion;”
“"Electronic communication," any transfer of signs, signals, writings, images, sounds, data, or intelligence of any nature transmitted by a wire, radio, electromagnetic, electronic, or optical system.”
“Install in any private place, without the consent of the person or persons entitled to privacy there, any device for observing, photographing, recording, amplifying, or broadcasting sounds or events in such place, or uses any such unauthorized installation.”
Does South Dakota law cover only private conversations?
For in-person talk, the law protects an "oral communication": one spoken by a person who shows an expectation that it is not subject to interception, in circumstances that justify that expectation. In State v. Owens (2002) the South Dakota Supreme Court held that a suspect who called his mother from a police interrogation room while he knew or suspected he was being taped had no such expectation, so the call was not a protected oral communication.[8][7]
What else changes the rule in South Dakota?
One party's consent covers phone calls as well as conversations in person. In State v. Braddock (1990) the South Dakota Supreme Court held that the consent of one party to the recording takes a call or conversation outside the state's wiretap law, building on State v. Woods (1985), which allowed a recording made with one party's consent and no court order.[2][3]
The person recording does not have to take part. The felony covers only someone who records without the consent of a sender or receiver (or, in person, of a party), so another person, such as an investigator or a recording service, may record with one participant's consent. In Braddock, officers recorded a call with the caller's permission.[1][2]
Woods and Braddock read an earlier text of § 23A-35A-20, which named telephone and telegraph communications. Amended in 2006 and 2017, the section now reaches any communication recorded with an "eavesdropping device". The South Dakota Supreme Court quoted the current text in Gantvoort v. Ranschau (2022) as the law that makes recordings without consent a crime.[3][1][9]
A separate misdemeanor, § 22-21-1, bars installing a device to record sounds or events in a private place without the consent of the people entitled to privacy there, or using such an installation. A private place is one where a person may reasonably expect to be safe from casual or hostile intrusion or surveillance, not one the public or a substantial group can enter. No South Dakota appellate decision applies § 22-21-1 to a participant's own recording of a conversation.[5][10]
Federal law also applies in South Dakota. It lets a party record a call or conversation unless the recording is made to commit a crime or a tort (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)). South Dakota's statute has no such purpose limit.[11][1]
A legal recording can still break a lawyer's ethics rules. In Midwest Motor Sports v. Arctic Cat (2003) the federal appeals court that covers South Dakota noted that South Dakota allows one-party recording, but upheld excluding the secret recordings a lawyer's investigator made of an opposing party's staff, as a sanction for contacting represented parties under false pretenses.[12]
What is the penalty for illegal recording in South Dakota?
Recording a call or conversation without the consent of any party, or helping someone do it, is a Class 5 felony (§ 23A-35A-20): up to 5 years in prison, and a fine of up to $10,000 may be added (§ 22-6-1). Installing a recording device in a private place without consent (§ 22-21-1) is a Class 1 misdemeanor: up to 1 year in county jail, a $2,000 fine, or both (§ 22-6-2).[1][4][5][6]
Can you sue over a recording in South Dakota?
South Dakota's wiretap chapter (SDCL ch. 23A-35A) gives no right to sue for damages. Federal law does: a person whose call is illegally intercepted, disclosed or used can recover actual damages and profits, or $100 a day or $10,000, whichever is greater (18 U.S.C. § 2520). The South Dakota Supreme Court also recognizes a claim for invasion of privacy by intrusion, and in Gantvoort v. Ranschau (2022), over a hidden recorder a wife left in her husband's office, it let his claim that her lawyer aided and abetted the intrusion go forward.[9][13][14][15]
What if the other person is outside South Dakota?
South Dakota's statute does not say which state's law governs a call with someone in another state. Federal law, which covers calls between states, also lets a participant record (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)). Courts in all-party states can apply their own law to calls with their residents: in Kearney (2006) the California Supreme Court applied California law to calls a Georgia office recorded with Californians.[16][1][11]
People on one call can be in states with different rules. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call. Check each state on your call here, or on the recording laws page.
Can a recording be used in court in South Dakota?
A recording made with one party's consent can be used in court, with no court order needed: the South Dakota Supreme Court upheld admitting an undercover agent's recording of a marijuana sale (State v. Woods, 1985) and a recorded phone call (State v. Braddock, 1990). Federal law bars evidence from an illegally intercepted call or conversation in any state court (18 U.S.C. § 2515). In the divorce behind Gantvoort (2022), the trial court refused to admit a wife's hidden recordings of her husband as made in violation of § 23A-35A-20.[3][2][17][9]
What are the exceptions in South Dakota?
The wiretap chapter does not apply to interception under a court order, the normal use of a phone company's services and equipment, the normal work of switchboard operators, phone company staff providing, repairing or protecting the service, answers to a subpoena or court order, or a carrier's help with a court-ordered interception (§ 23A-35A-21).[18]
A hearing aid used to correct hearing, and phone or other communication equipment a carrier supplies when it is used in the ordinary course of business, are not eavesdropping devices (§ 23A-35A-1(6)).[7]
The private-place device ban (§ 22-21-1(2)) does not apply to law enforcement officers, or people acting under their direction, while performing the officer's lawful duties.[5]
Does South Dakota law cover video?
A Zoom, Meet or Teams call is covered like a phone call. § 23A-35A-20 reaches any communication, and the chapter defines an electronic communication as any transfer of signs, signals, writings, images, sounds or data by a wire, radio, electromagnetic, electronic or optical system. A participant may record, and anyone else needs a participant's consent. No South Dakota appellate decision applies the statute to a video call.[7][1]
Recording Zoom, Google Meet or Teams calls in South Dakota
In South Dakota, a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call follows the rule for phone calls: one-party consent.[1][2][3]
A call with someone in Montana (all-party consent, notice is enough) also falls under that state' rule for video calls. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.
Callbox records Meet, Zoom and Teams calls from Chrome with no bot in the call; tell everyone on the call that you are recording. Compare it with other tools in the best meeting recorders without a bot.
Check your call
Pick the state of each other person on the call to see each one's rule.
The rules on your call
- South Dakota: one-party consent for callsSDCL § 23A-35A-20
Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.
Questions about recording calls in South Dakota
Is South Dakota a two-party consent state?
No. South Dakota needs the consent of one person on a phone call, who can be the one recording (SDCL § 23A-35A-20).
Can I record a Zoom, Meet or Teams call in South Dakota?
Yes, if you take part in the call or a participant agrees. The law covers any communication, including electronic ones made of sounds and images. Participants in other states can bring their own state's rules into play.
Do I have to announce that I am recording in South Dakota?
No. South Dakota law requires no beep or announcement when a participant records, or when one participant consents to the recording.
Can I record an in-person conversation in South Dakota?
Yes, if you are present or a party consents (SDCL § 23A-35A-20(2)). Installing a recording device in a private place, such as someone's home, without the consent of the people entitled to privacy there is a separate misdemeanor (§ 22-21-1).
What is the penalty for illegal recording in South Dakota?
Recording a call or conversation without any party's consent is a Class 5 felony: up to 5 years in prison, and a fine of up to $10,000 may be added (SDCL §§ 23A-35A-20, 22-6-1).
Can I sue someone who recorded me illegally in South Dakota?
South Dakota's wiretap law gives no right to sue, but federal law does (18 U.S.C. § 2520), and South Dakota courts allow a claim for invasion of privacy by intrusion (Gantvoort v. Ranschau, 2022).
The answers rest on these sources:[1][2][3][7][5][4][14][9][13]
Sources
- SDCL § 23A-35A-20 (overhearing or recording communications by means of eavesdropping device)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- State v. Braddock, 452 N.W.2d 785 (S.D. 1990)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- State v. Woods, 361 N.W.2d 620 (S.D. 1985)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- SDCL § 22-6-1 (felony classes and penalties)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- SDCL § 22-21-1 (eavesdropping, privacy, misdemeanor)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- SDCL § 22-6-2 (misdemeanor classes and penalties)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- SDCL § 23A-35A-1 (definitions)sdlegislature.gov, read on
- State v. Owens, 2002 SD 42, 643 N.W.2d 735www.courtlistener.com, read on
- Gantvoort v. Ranschau, 2022 S.D. 22, 973 N.W.2d 225ujs.sd.gov, read on (archived copy)
- SDCL § 22-1-2 (definitions: private place)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- 18 U.S.C. § 2511 (interception and disclosure of communications prohibited)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
- Midwest Motor Sports v. Arctic Cat Sales, Inc., 347 F.3d 693 (8th Cir. 2003)www.courtlistener.com, read on (archived copy)
- SDCL chapter 23A-35A (interception of wire, electronic, or oral communications)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
- 18 U.S.C. § 2520 (recovery of civil damages authorized)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Reporter's Recording Guide: South Dakotawww.rcfp.org, read on
- Kearney v. Salomon Smith Barney, Inc., 39 Cal. 4th 95 (2006)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- 18 U.S.C. § 2515 (prohibition of use as evidence of intercepted wire or oral communications)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
- SDCL § 23A-35A-21 (exemptions)sdlegislature.gov, read on (archived copy)
Changes to this page
- : Published
Last reviewed on . Researched and reviewed by the Callbox editorial team. Published by Techwarely LLC.
This page is not legal advice. Callbox is not a law firm. Laws change, and a court can read a law differently; ask a lawyer licensed in your state about your own case.
Found a mistake? Write to support@callbox.cc and we will check it against the source. How we research these pages.