Is Maryland a Two-Party Consent State?
Yes, Maryland is an all-party (two-party) consent state: in general, everyone on a call must agree to the recording.[1][2][3]
Maryland is an all-party (two-party) consent state: under the Wiretap Act, recording a phone call, video call or private conversation is a felony unless you take part in it and everyone has consented first (Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-402(c)(3)). Talking after hearing that a call is recorded counts as consent.[1][2][3]
- Phone calls
- All-party consent
- Video calls
- All-party consent
- In person
- All-party consent
- Penalty
- Recording a call or conversation without everyone's consent, or sharing or using one you know or have reason to know was recorded illegally, is a felony: up to 5 years in prison, a fine of up to $10,000, or both (§ 10-402(b)).[1]
- Delaware: disputed
- District of Columbia: one-party consent
- Maryland: all-party consent (this page)
- Pennsylvania: all-party consent
- Virginia: one-party consent
- West Virginia: one-party consent
- Disputed
- One-party consent
- All-party consent
All-party (often called two-party) consent means everyone on the call agrees to the recording; one-party consent means one person on the call, who can be the one recording, is enough.
Last reviewed on . Every fact links to its source. Not legal advice.
What does Maryland recording law say?
“It is lawful under this subtitle for a person to intercept a wire, oral, or electronic communication where the person is a party to the communication and where all of the parties to the communication have given prior consent to the interception”
“Willfully intercept, endeavor to intercept, or procure any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic communication”
““Oral communication” means any conversation or words spoken to or by any person in private conversation.”
Does Maryland law cover only private conversations?
For in-person talk, the Act protects only an "oral communication": words spoken "in private conversation". Maryland's highest court reads "private" by the Fourth Amendment test, whether a participant had a reasonable expectation of privacy (Agnew v. State, 2018). Whether a phone call must also be private is not settled. The definition of a wire communication, which covers phone calls, has no such words, and in the Fearnow case the Court of Special Appeals held privacy irrelevant to the interception of a phone call, but the Court of Appeals did not review that point (1996).[2][4][5]
What else changes the rule in Maryland?
Consent can be shown by conduct. In 2017 the Court of Special Appeals held that a jail inmate and his girlfriend consented to the recording of their call by talking after a recorded announcement said it would be recorded (Boston v. State). The inmate's brother, dialed in after the announcement, had not consented that way: the court found no evidence that he knew the call was recorded.[6][1]
The consent exception covers a person who is a party to the call or conversation, and even everyone's consent does not make a recording lawful when it is made to commit a crime or a tort (§ 10-402(c)(3)).[1]
The Act punishes only willful recording, and willful means intentional: the person recording does not have to know it is illegal, but a recording made by accident or simple negligence is not willful (Deibler v. State, 2001).[7][1]
A phone's recording app is covered like any other device. In 2018 the Court of Special Appeals upheld the exclusion of a mother's secret cell phone recording of a face-to-face conversation with her 8-year-old daughter (Holmes v. State). It held that the Act's exemption for phone equipment used in the ordinary course of business (§ 10-401(8)(i)), meant for extension phones, does not cover using a phone's recording app on a personal conversation. No Maryland court has decided whether a video platform's own record button falls under that exemption.[8][2]
Sharing or using the contents of a call or conversation you know or have reason to know was recorded illegally is the same felony as recording it (§ 10-402(a)(2) and (3)).[1]
What is the penalty for illegal recording in Maryland?
Recording a call or conversation without everyone's consent, or sharing or using one you know or have reason to know was recorded illegally, is a felony: up to 5 years in prison, a fine of up to $10,000, or both (§ 10-402(b)).[1]
Can you sue over a recording in Maryland?
A person whose call or conversation is recorded, disclosed or used illegally can sue for actual damages of at least $100 a day for each day of violation or $1,000, whichever is higher, plus punitive damages, a reasonable attorney's fee and litigation costs (§ 10-410(a)). Good faith reliance on a court order or legislative authorization is a complete defense (§ 10-410(b)).[9]
What if the other person is outside Maryland?
Maryland courts refuse a call recorded in another state, where it was lawful, if the recording would have broken Maryland's all-party rule. In Mustafa v. State (1991) the Court of Appeals excluded calls a man in the District of Columbia recorded with a person in Maryland: Maryland cannot ordinarily punish conduct outside its borders, but it decides what its courts admit. It did the same in 2016 with a call a victim recorded in West Virginia without police supervision (Seal v. State). § 10-405(b) admits such a recording only when, among other conditions, all parties were co-conspirators in a crime of violence. No Maryland court has decided whether recording from Maryland a call with someone in a one-party state is a crime. For police wiretaps, the Court of Appeals has held that a call is intercepted where its contents are first captured and heard (Davis v. State, 2012); applied to a private recording, that test points to Maryland's all-party rule for a call recorded in Maryland.[3][10][11][12]
People on one call can be in states with different rules. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call. Check each state on your call here, or on the recording laws page.
Can a recording be used in court in Maryland?
No part of an illegally recorded call or conversation, and no evidence derived from it, may be used in any trial, hearing or other proceeding in Maryland (§ 10-405(a)). The rule does not protect the person who made or agreed to the recording: the Court of Appeals held it can be used against them (Agnew v. State, 2018).[11][4]
What are the exceptions in Maryland?
A police officer, or someone acting at an officer's prior direction and under their supervision, may record with one party's consent to get evidence of listed crimes, such as murder, kidnapping, rape, robbery, bribery, extortion, drug dealing and human trafficking (§ 10-402(c)(2)). Handing a victim recording equipment to use alone in another state is not supervision (Seal v. State, 2016).[1][10]
Staff of a government emergency communications center may record a call or conversation about an emergency that they take part in (§ 10-402(c)(5)).[1]
Anyone may record an electronic communication sent through a system configured so that it is readily accessible to the general public (§ 10-402(c)(7)(i)).[1]
A police or correctional officer on regular duty may record a conversation with a body-worn camera, as part of a video recording, while in uniform or showing a badge, making reasonable efforts to follow the body-camera standards under Public Safety § 3-511 or Correctional Services § 8-211, taking part in the conversation, and telling the people recorded as soon as practicable, unless that is unsafe, impractical or impossible (§ 10-402(c)(11)).[1]
Does Maryland law cover video?
The Act covers Zoom, Google Meet and Teams calls whether their audio counts as a "wire communication" (a transfer containing the human voice made in whole or in part by wire or cable) or an "electronic communication", which includes sounds, images and data sent by wire, radio or similar systems. § 10-402 bans recording either kind without everyone's prior consent. No Maryland appeals court has yet decided a case about recording such a call. In Holmes v. State (2018) the Court of Special Appeals said that video without sound is not covered, but it was speaking of filming an in-person scene, such as video surveillance; it did not address a video call, whose images the definition of an electronic communication includes.[2][1][8]
Recording Zoom, Google Meet or Teams calls in Maryland
In Maryland, a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call follows the rule for phone calls: all-party consent.[1][2][3]
Callbox records Meet, Zoom and Teams calls from Chrome with no bot in the call; tell everyone on the call that you are recording. Compare it with other tools in the best meeting recorders without a bot.
Check your call
Pick the state of each other person on the call to see each one's rule.
The rules on your call
- Maryland: all-party consent for callsMd. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-402(c)(3)
Maryland needs all-party consent.
Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.
Questions about recording calls in Maryland
Can I record a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call in Maryland?
Only with the consent of everyone on it. The Wiretap Act covers wire and electronic communications, which include sounds and images sent in whole or in part by wire or radio (§ 10-401), and § 10-402 bans recording them without everyone's prior consent. People who keep talking after hearing that the call is recorded have consented by conduct (Boston v. State, 2017).
Is announcing the recording enough in Maryland?
Yes, if you announce it before you record and the others keep talking: in Boston v. State (2017) the Court of Special Appeals held that people who talked after a recorded warning had consented. Someone who joins after the announcement and did not hear it has not consented that way.
What is the penalty for recording a call illegally in Maryland?
It is a felony: up to 5 years in prison, a fine of up to $10,000, or both (§ 10-402(b)). The person recorded can also sue for at least $1,000 or $100 a day, whichever is higher, plus punitive damages and attorney's fees (§ 10-410).
Can someone in another state record a call with me in Maryland?
Maryland cannot ordinarily punish what is done outside the state, but its courts will not admit such a recording as evidence if it would have broken Maryland's all-party rule (Mustafa v. State, 1991; Seal v. State, 2016). § 10-405(b) makes a narrow exception for recordings of co-conspirators in a crime of violence.
Can I record a call from Maryland with someone in a one-party state?
Not safely without everyone's consent. No Maryland court has decided it, but the Court of Appeals has held, for police wiretaps, that a call is intercepted where its contents are first captured and heard (Davis v. State, 2012), which points to Maryland's all-party rule for a call recorded in Maryland.
Can I record an in-person conversation in Maryland?
Not a private one without everyone's consent. The Act protects words spoken in private conversation, judged by whether a participant reasonably expected privacy (Agnew v. State, 2018). Silent video of an in-person scene, such as video surveillance, is not covered (Holmes v. State, 2018).
Can an illegal recording be used in court in Maryland?
Generally no: § 10-405 bars an illegally recorded call or conversation, and any evidence derived from it, from Maryland courts and other proceedings. It can be used against the person who made or agreed to the recording (Agnew v. State, 2018).
The answers rest on these sources:[2][1][6][9][3][10][11][12][4][8]
Sources
- Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-402 Interception of communications (Maryland General Assembly)mgaleg.maryland.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-401 Definitions (Maryland General Assembly)mgaleg.maryland.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Mustafa v. State, 323 Md. 65 (1991)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- Agnew v. State, 461 Md. 672 (2018) (court PDF, No. 9, Sept. Term 2018)www.mdcourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Fearnow v. Chesapeake & Potomac Telephone Co., 342 Md. 363 (1996)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- Boston v. State, 235 Md. App. 134 (2017) (court PDF, No. 871, Sept. Term 2016)www.mdcourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Deibler v. State, 365 Md. 185 (2001)www.courtlistener.com, read on
- Holmes v. State, 236 Md. App. 636 (2018) (court PDF, No. 2575, Sept. Term 2016)www.mdcourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-410 Civil action (Maryland General Assembly)mgaleg.maryland.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Seal v. State, 447 Md. 64 (2016) (court PDF, No. 51, Sept. Term 2015)www.mdcourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-405 Admissibility of intercepted communications (Maryland General Assembly)mgaleg.maryland.gov, read on (archived copy)
- Davis v. State, 426 Md. 211 (2012) (court PDF, No. 59, Sept. Term 2011)www.mdcourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
Changes to this page
- : Published
Last reviewed on . Researched and reviewed by the Callbox editorial team. Published by Techwarely LLC.
This page is not legal advice. Callbox is not a law firm. Laws change, and a court can read a law differently; ask a lawyer licensed in your state about your own case.
Found a mistake? Write to support@callbox.cc and we will check it against the source. How we research these pages.