Is New York a One-Party Consent State?

Yes. New York is a one-party consent state: recording a call or conversation is the felony of eavesdropping only when no party to it consents (N.Y. Penal Law §§ 250.00, 250.05). The Court of Appeals held it is not unlawful to record a phone call with one party's consent (People v. Lasher, 1983).[1][2][3][4]

Phone calls
One-party consent
Video calls
One-party consent
In person
One-party consent
Penalty
Eavesdropping is a class E felony (Penal Law § 250.05). A prison sentence can run up to 4 years (§ 70.00(2)(e)), or, for someone who is not a second or persistent felony offender, the court can set a definite term of 1 year or less (§ 70.00(4)). The fine can be up to $5,000 or double the defendant's gain from the crime, whichever is higher (§ 80.00).[2][5][6]
  • Connecticut: all-party consent for phone calls, not settled for video calls
  • Massachusetts: coming soon
  • New Jersey: coming soon
  • New York: one-party consent (this page)
  • Pennsylvania: all-party consent
  • Vermont: coming soon
  • All-party consent
  • One-party consent
  • Coming soon
  • Video call rule not settled

All-party (often called two-party) consent means everyone on the call agrees to the recording; one-party consent means one person on the call, who can be the one recording, is enough.

Last reviewed on . Every fact links to its source. Not legal advice.

What does New York recording law say?

N.Y. Penal Law § 250.05, Eavesdropping[2]
“A person is guilty of eavesdropping when he unlawfully engages in wiretapping, mechanical overhearing of a conversation, or intercepting or accessing of an electronic communication.”
N.Y. Penal Law § 250.00(1), Eavesdropping; definitions of terms (wiretapping)[1]
“"Wiretapping" means the intentional overhearing or recording of a telephonic or telegraphic communication by a person other than a sender or receiver thereof, without the consent of either the sender or receiver, by means of any instrument, device or equipment.”
N.Y. Penal Law § 250.00(2), Eavesdropping; definitions of terms (mechanical overhearing of a conversation)[1]
“"Mechanical overhearing of a conversation" means the intentional overhearing or recording of a conversation or discussion, without the consent of at least one party thereto, by a person not present thereat, by means of any instrument, device or equipment.”
N.Y. Penal Law § 250.00(6), Eavesdropping; definitions of terms (intercepting or accessing of an electronic communication)[1]
“the intentional acquiring, receiving, collecting, overhearing, or recording of an electronic communication, without the consent of the sender or intended receiver thereof, by means of any instrument, device or equipment”

What else changes the rule in New York?

Taking part in a call does not cover recording a face-to-face conversation heard through it. In People v. Badalamenti (2016) a father on an open cell phone line recorded the people in the room at the other end; the Court of Appeals held this matched "mechanical overhearing", since he was not present at that conversation. Only his consent on behalf of his child made it lawful.[7][1]

New York's definition of a phone call has no expectation-of-privacy test. In People v. Fata (1990) the Appellate Division held that intentionally intercepting a cordless phone call is eavesdropping under state law, although federal law did not then protect such calls.[8]

Federal law also applies in New York, and it makes a participant's recording illegal when it is made to commit a crime or a tort (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)).[9]

New York's eavesdropping law does not reach someone present at a conversation, even one not taking part in it. In McLaughlin v. McLaughlin (2013) the Appellate Division held that a son who recorded his parents from his bedroom was "present", so his recording did not break the statute and was admitted. Federal law's exception covers only a party or someone with a party's consent (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)), so recording a private conversation you are not part of can still be a federal crime.[10][1][9]

What is the penalty for illegal recording in New York?

Eavesdropping is a class E felony (Penal Law § 250.05). A prison sentence can run up to 4 years (§ 70.00(2)(e)), or, for someone who is not a second or persistent felony offender, the court can set a definite term of 1 year or less (§ 70.00(4)). The fine can be up to $5,000 or double the defendant's gain from the crime, whichever is higher (§ 80.00).[2][5][6]

Can you sue over a recording in New York?

Penal Law article 250 has no section that lets the person recorded sue, and the Appellate Division found no civil cause of action in a violation of its § 250.30 (Greenfield v. Schultz, 1998). New York has no common-law privacy tort either: the Court of Appeals held privacy is governed only by Civil Rights Law §§ 50 and 51 (Howell v. New York Post, 1993). Federal law does let a person whose call was illegally intercepted sue (18 U.S.C. § 2520): the court may award the greater of actual damages plus the violator's profits, or statutory damages of $100 a day or $10,000, whichever is greater, and punitive damages in appropriate cases, plus attorney's fees. The suit must be brought within two years of the first reasonable chance to discover the violation (§ 2520(e)). In Locke v. Aston (2006), a one-party taping lawful under New York law, which governed there, gave the New Yorker recorded no damages claim under California's all-party law.[11][12][13][14][4]

What if the other person is outside New York?

New York courts choose the law that governs a civil claim by asking which state has the greater interest in the case. In Locke v. Aston (2006) a Californian taped calls with a New Yorker who was in New York, and he sought damages under California's all-party law. The Appellate Division held that California's statute protects Californians, not a New Yorker outside California, and that, even if it did, New York law applied because the New Yorker lived in New York and the alleged injury occurred there, where one-party taping is lawful. Courts in all-party states can apply their own law the other way: in Kearney (2006) the California Supreme Court applied California law to calls a Georgia office recorded with Californians.[4][15]

People on one call can be in states with different rules. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call. Check each state on your call here, or on the recording laws page.

Can a recording be used in court in New York?

A recording made by committing the crime of eavesdropping, and evidence derived from it, cannot be used in any New York court, grand jury or state agency proceeding, except against the person accused of the eavesdropping (CPLR 4506). The bar covers recordings made by private individuals, not only by the police (People v. Capolongo, 1995). A lawful one-party recording is not excluded: in People v. Lasher (1983) the Court of Appeals refused to suppress tapes the person called had made.[16][17][3]

What are the exceptions in New York?

A parent or guardian may consent for a minor child to the recording of the child's conversation, if the parent believes in good faith that the recording is necessary for the child's best interests and that belief has an objectively reasonable basis (People v. Badalamenti, 2016). Its holding is limited to recording a conversation ("mechanical overhearing", § 250.00(2)); it did not address the tapping of the child's own phone calls.[7][1]

Eavesdropping is a crime only when done "unlawfully": recording authorized by a warrant or order under Criminal Procedure Law article 700 or 705 is not eavesdropping.[1][2]

The normal operation of a telephone company, and what it needs to protect its rights or property, is not wiretapping.[1]

Does New York law cover video?

A video call is covered whether its sound counts as a "telephonic communication" (any transfer of the human voice by wire or cable) or the call counts as an "electronic communication" (a transfer of images, sounds or data). Both definitions make recording a crime only without the consent of a sender or receiver, so a participant may record a Zoom, Meet or Teams call.[1]

Recording Zoom, Google Meet or Teams calls in New York

In New York, a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call follows the rule for phone calls: one-party consent.[1][2][3][4]

A call with someone in Pennsylvania (all-party consent) also falls under that state' rule for video calls. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.

Callbox records Meet, Zoom and Teams calls from Chrome with no bot in the call; tell everyone on the call that you are recording. Compare it with other tools in the best meeting recorders without a bot.

Check your call

Pick the state of each other person on the call to see each one's rule.

The rules on your call

  • New York: one-party consent for callsN.Y. Penal Law § 250.05

Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.

Questions about recording calls in New York

Is New York a two-party consent state?

No. New York needs the consent of one person on a phone call, who can be the one recording (N.Y. Penal Law § 250.05).

Can I record a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call in New York?

Yes, if you take part in the call or a participant agrees. New York's law covers electronic communications, including images and sounds, and makes recording one a crime only without the consent of the sender or an intended receiver.

Can I record an in-person conversation in New York?

Yes, if you take part in it. "Mechanical overhearing" is recording a conversation by a person not present, without the consent of at least one party, so a recorder left running in a room you are not in needs a participant's consent.

What is the penalty for illegal eavesdropping in New York?

Eavesdropping is a class E felony: up to 4 years in prison, or a definite term of 1 year or less, and a fine of up to $5,000 or double the defendant's gain.

Can a recording be used as evidence in a New York court?

A lawful one-party recording can be. A recording made by committing the crime of eavesdropping cannot, by anyone, except in a case against the eavesdropper (CPLR 4506).

Does New York law apply when I record someone in another state?

Not necessarily. In one civil suit between people domiciled in different states, a New York court applied the law of the place where the person recorded was injured: New York's one-party rule, for a New Yorker taped from California (Locke v. Aston, 2006). A court in an all-party state such as California can apply its own law to a call with someone there.

The answers rest on these sources:[1][2][3][4][7][5][6][16][17][15]

Sources

  1. N.Y. Penal Law § 250.00 Eavesdropping; definitions of terms (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on (archived copy)
  2. N.Y. Penal Law § 250.05 Eavesdropping (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on (archived copy)
  3. People v. Lasher, 58 N.Y.2d 962 (1983)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  4. Locke v. Aston, 31 A.D.3d 33 (1st Dep't 2006)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  5. N.Y. Penal Law § 70.00 Sentence of imprisonment for felony (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on (archived copy)
  6. N.Y. Penal Law § 80.00 Fine for felony (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on (archived copy)
  7. People v. Badalamenti, 27 N.Y.3d 423 (2016)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  8. People v. Fata, 159 A.D.2d 180 (2d Dep't 1990)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  9. 18 U.S.C. § 2511 Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (govinfo)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
  10. McLaughlin v. McLaughlin, 104 A.D.3d 1315 (4th Dep't 2013)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  11. N.Y. Penal Law article 250, Offenses Against the Right to Privacy (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on
  12. Howell v. New York Post Co., 81 N.Y.2d 115 (1993)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  13. Greenfield v. Schultz, 251 A.D.2d 67 (1st Dep't 1998)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  14. 18 U.S.C. § 2520 Recovery of civil damages authorized (govinfo)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
  15. Kearney v. Salomon Smith Barney, Inc., 39 Cal. 4th 95 (2006)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  16. N.Y. CPLR 4506 Eavesdropping evidence; admissibility (NY Senate)www.nysenate.gov, read on (archived copy)
  17. People v. Capolongo, 85 N.Y.2d 151 (1995)www.courtlistener.com, read on

Changes to this page

  • : Published

Last reviewed on . Researched and reviewed by the Callbox editorial team. Published by Techwarely LLC.

This page is not legal advice. Callbox is not a law firm. Laws change, and a court can read a law differently; ask a lawyer licensed in your state about your own case.

Found a mistake? Write to support@callbox.cc and we will check it against the source. How we research these pages.