Is Michigan a One-Party Consent State?

Yes. Michigan is a one-party consent state as its courts read the law: the statute (MCL 750.539a, 750.539c) covers only "the private discourse of others", so you can record a call or conversation you take part in (Sullivan v. Gray, 1982). The state Supreme Court has not ruled. In a private place, § 750.539d may also apply.[1][2][3][4]

Phone calls
One-party consent
Video calls
One-party consent
In person
One-party consent
Penalty
Eavesdropping is a felony punishable by up to 2 years in state prison, a fine of up to $2,000, or both (§ 750.539c); the sentencing guidelines list it as a class H public order offense (MCL 777.16aa). Using or divulging information you know or reasonably should know came from illegal eavesdropping is a felony with up to 2 years in prison or a fine of up to $2,000 (§ 750.539e). Using a recording device in a private place without consent (§ 750.539d) is a felony with up to 2 years, a fine of up to $2,000, or both, and up to 5 years, $5,000, or both for a repeat offense or for distributing a recording you know or have reason to know was made in violation of it.[1][5][6][7]
  • Indiana: coming soon
  • Michigan: one-party consent (this page)
  • Ohio: one-party consent
  • Wisconsin: coming soon
  • One-party consent
  • Coming soon

All-party (often called two-party) consent means everyone on the call agrees to the recording; one-party consent means one person on the call, who can be the one recording, is enough.

Last reviewed on . Every fact links to its source. Not legal advice.

What does Michigan recording law say?

MCL 750.539c, Eavesdropping upon private conversation[1]
“Any person who is present or who is not present during a private conversation and who wilfully uses any device to eavesdrop upon the conversation without the consent of all parties thereto”
MCL 750.539a(2), Definitions (eavesdropping)[2]
“"Eavesdrop" or "eavesdropping" means to overhear, record, amplify or transmit any part of the private discourse of others without the permission of all persons engaged in the discourse.”
MCL 750.539d(1)(a), Installation, placement, or use of device in private place[7]
“Install, place, or use in any private place, without the consent of the person or persons entitled to privacy in that place, any device for observing, recording, transmitting, photographing, or eavesdropping upon the sounds or events in that place.”

Does Michigan law cover only private conversations?

The law protects only a "private conversation". The Michigan Supreme Court defined it as a conversation a person reasonably expects to be free from casual or hostile intrusion or surveillance, and held that whether a conversation is private generally is a question of fact (People v. Stone, 2001).[8]

What else changes the rule in Michigan?

The Michigan Supreme Court has never decided whether a participant may record without the others' consent. A federal court asked it to answer that question, and in May 2021 it declined (one justice would have answered). The statute's text says "all parties", and the dissent in Sullivan v. Gray read it to cover participants too.[9][3]

Federal courts now follow Sullivan. In 2019 a federal trial court in AFT Michigan v. Project Veritas predicted that the Michigan Supreme Court would require all parties' consent; after that court declined to answer, the trial court reversed itself in November 2021. In Fisher v. Perron (2022) the Sixth Circuit, the federal appeals court covering Michigan, held that a participant does not violate the statute by recording without the others' consent.[4][10][11]

Only a participant may record on their own consent. A person who is not taking part needs the consent of all parties, and a participant cannot authorize someone else to listen in or record for them: the statute also punishes whoever aids, employs or procures another person to eavesdrop. No Michigan case read in this pass says whether a meeting bot or live transcription service that a participant adds to a call counts as someone else listening in.[3][1]

Recording is not the same as relaying the talk live. In Dickerson v. Raphael (1999), as quoted in Lewis v. LeGrow (2003), the Michigan Supreme Court said a participant may not secretly broadcast a private conversation.[12]

A separate section, § 750.539d, makes it a felony to install or use a device in a private place to record the sounds or events there without the consent of the people entitled to privacy in that place. In Lewis v. LeGrow (2003) the Court of Appeals applied it to a man who secretly videotaped sex in his own bedroom: being present did not let him record. No Michigan case read in this pass applies § 750.539d to a participant's audio recording of a conversation.[7][12]

Talk that is plainly exposed is not private. In Bowens v. ARY (2011) the Michigan Supreme Court held that no reasonable juror could find a backstage conversation private when people were free to come and go from the room and a cameraman was openly filming in it.[13]

Federal law also applies in Michigan. It lets a party record a call or conversation, unless the recording is made to commit a crime or a tort (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)).[14][4]

What is the penalty for illegal recording in Michigan?

Eavesdropping is a felony punishable by up to 2 years in state prison, a fine of up to $2,000, or both (§ 750.539c); the sentencing guidelines list it as a class H public order offense (MCL 777.16aa). Using or divulging information you know or reasonably should know came from illegal eavesdropping is a felony with up to 2 years in prison or a fine of up to $2,000 (§ 750.539e). Using a recording device in a private place without consent (§ 750.539d) is a felony with up to 2 years, a fine of up to $2,000, or both, and up to 5 years, $5,000, or both for a repeat offense or for distributing a recording you know or have reason to know was made in violation of it.[1][5][6][7]

Can you sue over a recording in Michigan?

Any party to a conversation eavesdropped on in violation of the law can get an injunction against further eavesdropping, all actual damages from the eavesdropper, and punitive damages set by the court or a jury (§ 750.539h). The statute sets no minimum amount.[15]

What if the other person is outside Michigan?

No Michigan statute or case read in this pass says which state's law governs a call with someone in another state. In Fisher v. Perron (2022) a woman in Michigan recorded a call with her siblings in Michigan, Virginia and Washington; the Sixth Circuit applied Michigan's statute and found no violation because she took part in the call. Courts in all-party states can apply their own law to calls with their residents: in Kearney (2006) the California Supreme Court applied California law to calls an Atlanta office recorded with Californians.[4][16]

People on one call can be in states with different rules. Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call. Check each state on your call here, or on the recording laws page.

Can a recording be used in court in Michigan?

Michigan's eavesdropping law has no exclusionary rule. In People v. Livingston (1975) the Court of Appeals refused to suppress a recording a private citizen made in violation of § 750.539c, because the Legislature chose criminal and civil penalties instead. A participant's own recording is not eavesdropping, so the statute gives no ground to exclude it (People v. Williams, 2020, unpublished). Using or divulging information from a recording you know or reasonably should know was illegal is itself a felony (§ 750.539e).[17][18][6]

What are the exceptions in Michigan?

The eavesdropping sections do not prohibit eavesdropping or surveillance by a state or federal peace officer, or the officer's agent, in the performance of the officer's duties, when no other law prohibits it.[19]

They also allow a phone company employee to hear calls in the course of the job, a public utility to record customer calls asking for service or making a complaint when it needs the record for legitimate business purposes and its staff know of the practice, and the routine monitoring of prison phones by the department of corrections.[19]

The private-place section does not prohibit security monitoring in a home by or at the direction of its owner or principal occupant, unless it is done for a lewd or lascivious purpose.[7]

Does Michigan law cover video?

A Zoom, Meet or Teams call is covered like a phone call: § 750.539c reaches any private conversation recorded with "any device", whatever carries it, so a participant may record and an outsider needs everyone's consent. What you say with your microphone on may not be private: in Kosch v. Traverse City Area Public Schools (2024) the Court of Appeals concluded that a teacher's conversation with her husband was not private when her open microphone broadcast it to a virtual classroom open to her students, so the student who recorded it did not violate § 750.539c. Separately, willfully and maliciously tapping or making an unauthorized connection with any electronic medium of communication, including the internet, is a felony: up to 2 years, a fine of up to $1,000, or both (§ 750.540).[1][3][20][21]

Recording Zoom, Google Meet or Teams calls in Michigan

In Michigan, a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call follows the rule for phone calls: one-party consent.[1][2][3][4]

Callbox records Meet, Zoom and Teams calls from Chrome with no bot in the call; tell everyone on the call that you are recording. Compare it with other tools in the best meeting recorders without a bot.

Check your call

Pick the state of each other person on the call to see each one's rule.

The rules on your call

  • Michigan: one-party consent for callsMCL 750.539c

Follow the stricter rule: get consent from everyone on the call.

Questions about recording calls in Michigan

Is Michigan a one-party or two-party consent state?

One-party for the people on the call, as the courts read the law. MCL 750.539c says all parties must consent, but the Court of Appeals holds that eavesdropping means recording other people's conversations, so a participant may record (Sullivan v. Gray, 1982; Lewis v. LeGrow, 2003). The Michigan Supreme Court declined to decide the question in 2021.

Can I record a Zoom, Google Meet or Teams call in Michigan?

Yes, if you take part in the call. The eavesdropping law covers private conversations recorded with any device, and the courts hold that it does not apply to a participant's own recording.

Can someone who is not on the call record it in Michigan if one person agrees?

No. A person who is not taking part needs the consent of all parties (MCL 750.539c). One participant's consent is not enough (Sullivan v. Gray).

Can I record an in-person conversation in Michigan?

Yes, if you take part in it, but in a private place, such as someone's home, § 750.539d may also apply: it bars using a recording device there without the consent of the people entitled to privacy, and the Court of Appeals applied it to a participant who secretly videotaped (Lewis v. LeGrow).

Do I have to announce that I am recording in Michigan?

Not if you take part in the call: no Michigan statute requires a beep or an announcement for a participant's recording. Someone who is not taking part needs the consent of all parties.

What is the penalty for illegal recording in Michigan?

Eavesdropping is a felony: up to 2 years in prison, a fine of up to $2,000, or both (MCL 750.539c). The people recorded can also sue for an injunction, actual damages and punitive damages (§ 750.539h).

The answers rest on these sources:[1][3][12][9][4][7][15]

Sources

  1. MCL 750.539c Eavesdropping upon private conversation (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  2. MCL 750.539a Definitions (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  3. Sullivan v. Gray, 117 Mich. App. 476 (1982)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  4. Fisher v. Perron, 30 F.4th 289 (6th Cir. 2022) (court PDF, No. 21-1184)www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov, read on (archived copy)
  5. MCL 777.16aa Sentencing guidelines: MCL 750.539c to 750.540g (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  6. MCL 750.539e Using or divulging information obtained by eavesdropping (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  7. MCL 750.539d Device in a private place (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  8. People v. Stone, 463 Mich. 558 (2001)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  9. In re Certified Question (AFT Michigan v. Project Veritas), Michigan Supreme Court order, No. 162121 (May 26, 2021)www.courts.michigan.gov, read on
  10. AFT Michigan v. Project Veritas, 378 F. Supp. 3d 614 (E.D. Mich. 2019)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  11. AFT Michigan v. Project Veritas, No. 17-13292 (E.D. Mich. Nov. 8, 2021) (order on reconsideration)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  12. Lewis v. LeGrow, 258 Mich. App. 175 (2003)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  13. Bowens v. ARY, Inc., Michigan Supreme Court order, No. 140296 (2011)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  14. 18 U.S.C. § 2511 Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (govinfo)www.govinfo.gov, 2024 edition, read on
  15. MCL 750.539h Civil remedies (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  16. Kearney v. Salomon Smith Barney, Inc., 39 Cal. 4th 95 (2006)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  17. People v. Livingston, 64 Mich. App. 247 (1975)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  18. People v. Williams, No. 346689 (Mich. Ct. App. May 21, 2020) (unpublished)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  19. MCL 750.539g Exceptions (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)
  20. Kosch v. Traverse City Area Public Schools, No. 364955 (Mich. Ct. App. Aug. 22, 2024) (published)www.courtlistener.com, read on
  21. MCL 750.540 Use of electronic medium of communication (Michigan Legislature)www.legislature.mi.gov, read on (archived copy)

Changes to this page

  • : Published

Last reviewed on . Researched and reviewed by the Callbox editorial team. Published by Techwarely LLC.

This page is not legal advice. Callbox is not a law firm. Laws change, and a court can read a law differently; ask a lawyer licensed in your state about your own case.

Found a mistake? Write to support@callbox.cc and we will check it against the source. How we research these pages.